The information contained in this report is provided in compliance with the Oklahoma Open Records Act, 51 O.S. 24A.1. Use of this information is governed by this act, as well as other applicable state and federal laws.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA

Jared Upton,
Petitioner,

vs.

City of Tulsa,
Respondent.
No. WCM-115557
(Workers' Compensation Commission)


Filed: 11/28/2016
Closed: 10/17/2018

Appealed from: Workers' Compensation Commission

Filed Opinion/Order
  2018 OK 69 , 428 P.3d 314

Parties

City Of Tulsa, Respondent
UPTON, JARED, Petitioner
 

Attorneys

Attorney Represented Parties
Bell,  Richard  A. (Bar #685)
3151 W. TECUMSEH RD.
SUITE 100
NORMAN, OK 73072
 
 
BURKE,  BOB (Bar #1329)
512 NORTH BROADWAY AVE STE 300
OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73102
 
UPTON  JARED
Green,  Michael  R (Bar #13397)
3739 East 31st Street
Tulsa, OK 74135
 
UPTON  JARED
Hall,  Nathan  B
313 NE 21st Street
*******Interagency mail*********

 
 
Hermes,  John (Bar #4133)
McAfee & Taft, A Professional Corporation
Tenth Floor, Leadership Square
211 North Robinson
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
 
 
Inman,  Brandy  Lynn (Bar #22187)
7906 E. 33rd Street
Suite 100
Tulsa, OK 74145
 
 
Kuperman,  Steven  O
10441 S. Regal Blvd, Suite 200
Tulsa, OK 74133
 
City Of Tulsa
Mansinghani,  Mithun  Suresh (Bar #32453)
629 W. Main St
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
 
 
Morris,  Andrew  J (Bar #31658)
MCAFEE & TAFT PC
10TH FLOOR, TWO LEADERSHIP SQUARE
211 N. ROBINSON
OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73102
 
 

Events

  None

Lower Court Counts and Other Information

Count Case Number Statute Crime Sentence Judge Reporter
- CM-2014-7767 R - Administrative Law Judges

Docket

Date Code Description Count Party Amount
11-18-2016  DOOA

DATE OF ORDER APPEALED

11-28-2016  CASE

WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSION INITIAL FILING

11-28-2016  PAY

RECEIPT # 67926 ON 11/28/2016.
PAYOR: BOB BURKE TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 200.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$200.00 ON WORKERS' COMPENSATION COMMISSION INITIAL FILING.

11-28-2016  PETF

PETITION FOR REVIEW FILED BY BURKE FOR UPTON-PETR

Document Available (#1034516036) TIFF    PDF

11-28-2016  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY RICHARD BELL

Document Available (#1034516040) TIFF    PDF

11-28-2016  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY BOB BURKE

Document Available (#1034516044) TIFF    PDF

11-28-2016  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY MICHAEL R. GREEN

Document Available (#1034516048) TIFF    PDF

11-28-2016  DSRC

DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1034516052) TIFF    PDF

11-29-2016  MRGR

JE: ON CT'S MOT, TH/MATTER IS RETAINED FOR DISPO IN OKLA SUP CT. C/ATTYS WCM

Document Available (#1034515080) TIFF    PDF

11-30-2016  COMP

JE: PETRS' MOTIONS TO COMBINE TH/CASES (115557, 115558) GRANTED, AND THESE TWO CASES ARE MADE COMPANION CASES ETC. TH/SHALL CONTAIN SEPARATE RECS, AND BE BRIEFED SEPARATELY, BUT ASSIGNED TO THE SAME REVIEWING CT FOR DISPO. PETR'S MOT TO EXPEDITE, FILED IN CASE 115558, DENIED. TH/CASES ARE ALREADY PROCEEDING PURSUANT TO AN EXPEDITED SCHEDULE. NTCP DUE TO BE FILED 1-12-17, AND BRIEFING SH/BE COMPLETED SHORTLY THEREAFTER. ETC. N/ATTYS WCM

Document Available (#1034515454) TIFF    PDF

12-14-2016  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY BRANDY L. INMAN AND STEVEN KUPERMAN

Document Available (#1034517463) TIFF    PDF

12-14-2016  RESP

RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR REVIEW

Document Available (#1034517467) TIFF    PDF

01-12-2017  NTCP

NOTICE OF COMPLETION

Document Available (#1034517615) TIFF    PDF

01-27-2017  ATBC

PETITIONER'S BRIEF IN CHIEF

Document Available (#1035748600) TIFF    PDF

01-31-2017  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY NATHAN B. HALL

Document Available (#1035749560) TIFF    PDF

01-31-2017  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY MITHUN S. MANSINGHANI

Document Available (#1035749564) TIFF    PDF

01-31-2017  TEXT

NOTICE OF INTENT TO EXERCISE RIGHT TO EXPRESS VIEWS OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

Document Available (#1035749568) TIFF    PDF

02-09-2017  TEXT

JE: CT NOTES ATTY GENERAL'S EXERCISE OF THE RIGHT TO BE HEARD IN THIS MATTER, ATTY GENERAL SH/BE PROVIDED THE OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN ANY BRIEFING OR ARGUMENT. ATTY GENERAL MAY FILE BRIEF WITHIN 15 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF TH/ORDER. C/ATTYS WCM

Document Available (#1035748745) TIFF    PDF

02-13-2017  COMP

JE: PET FILED MOT TO RETAIN APPEAL ETC. PETR REQUESTS MATTER BE MADE COMP TO 115557 AND 115558 ETC. PETR'S REQ GRANTED. 115717 SHALL CONTAIN SEP REC AND BE BRIEFED SEPARATELY, BUT ASSIGNED TO SAME REVIEWING CT FOR DISP. ATTY GENERAL HAS EXCERCISED RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE IN 115557 AND 115558. CT NOTES ATTY GENERAL'S RIGHT TO BE HEARD ETC, ATTY GENERAL SH/BE PROVIDED OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN ANY BRIEFING AND ARGUMENT. CLERK TO MAIL COPY OF PETR'S PET FOR REVIEW ETC, AND PETR'S MOT TO RETAIN APPEAL ETC. ATTY GEN INVITED TO FILE BRIEF W/IN 20 DAYS FR/.DATE OF FILING OF NTCP. CT ALSO NOTES PETR'S MOT TO RETAIN APPEAL AND COMBINE W/OHTER PENDING CASES MAKES STATEMENT TH/APPEALS AND COMPLETIONS OF REC WILL BE FILED 2-1-17, W/SUB BRIEFING IN ALL THREE CASES TO FOLLOW SHORTLY TH/AFTER. CT DENIED PETR'S MOT TO EXPEDITE IN 115557 AND 115558. WE DENY EXPEDITED BRIEFING AS WELL. PETR'S BRIEF FILED 1-27-17, IS PREMATURE. RULE 1.105, ETC, PROVIDES ATBC SH/BE FILED W/IN TWENTY DAYS FR/DATE OF FILING OF NTCP. NO NTCP HAS BEEN FILED ETC. BECAUSE OF PREMATURE FILING, ANSWER AND REPLY BRIEFING SCHEDULE SH/NOT BEGIN UNTIL NTCP HAS BEEN FILED AND AS IF ATBC WAS FILED SAME DAY AS FILING OF NTCP. C/ATTYS WCM (COPIES OF PET FOR REVIEW AND MOT TO RETAIN TO ATTY GENERAL)******TYPO*****

Document Available (#1035749756) TIFF    PDF

02-13-2017  AEAB

RESPONDENTS' ANSWER BRIEF

Document Available (#1035748754) TIFF    PDF

02-23-2017  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ANDREW J. MORRIS

Document Available (#1035750783) TIFF    PDF

02-23-2017  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY JOHN N. HERMES

Document Available (#1035750787) TIFF    PDF

02-23-2017  ACBR

AMICUS CURIAE THE STATE CHAMBER OF OKLAHOMA'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS (WRITTEN CONSENT OF ALL PARTIES ON ENTRY OF APPEARANCE)

Document Available (#1035750791) TIFF    PDF

02-24-2017  AEAB

ATTORNEY GENERAL'S BRIEF ON THE MERITS OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL CLAIMS

Document Available (#1035749004) TIFF    PDF

03-10-2017  RORD

RECORD ORDERED

03-23-2017  ORGR

ORIGINAL RECORD - 175 PAGES; 1 VOLUME OF EXHIBITS; 1 BOUND DOCUMENT (MOT. TO EXCL. EXPERT WITNESS TESTIMONY)

03-23-2017  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 7/21/16 - 52 PAGES

03-23-2017  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 11/17/16 - 21 PAGES

03-23-2017  TEXT

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA-NATHAN B. HALL

Document Available (#1035752771) TIFF    PDF

03-24-2017  RCCT

RECORD TO COURT

03-24-2017  ASNJ

ASSIGNED TO SUPREME COURT

03-24-2017  TEXT

JE: IN FOLLOWING CASES (115635, 115558, 115620, 115717, 115557) MOT OF NATHAN B. HALL TO W/DRAW AS ATTY FOR ST OF OKLA GRANTED, ATTY HALL PRMTD TO W/DRAW. STATE OF OKLA VIEWS OF AG WILL CONT TO BE REP BY MANSINGHANI ETC. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1035752014) TIFF    PDF

04-26-2017  TEXT

JE: I H/BY RECUSE MYSELF ETC. COLBERT, J. C/ATTYS WCM

Document Available (#1036604838) TIFF    PDF

01-10-2018  TEXT

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD-ANDREW J. MORRIS

Document Available (#1038835099) TIFF    PDF

01-11-2018  TEXT

JE: MOT TO W/DRAW OF MORRIS ETC GRANTED, MORRIS PRMTD TO W/DRAW. STATE CHAMBER OF OKLA WILL CONT TO BE REP BY HERMES ETC. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1038835104) TIFF    PDF

05-18-2018  TEXT

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD-BRANDY L. INMAN

Document Available (#1040396524) TIFF    PDF

05-22-2018  TEXT

JE: MOT OF ATTY INMAN TO W/DRAW GRANTED UPON FILING OF ENTRY OF APP SIGNED BY EACH ATTY WHO WILL BE CONT TO REP CITY OF TULSA ETC. CT NOTES KUPERMAN LISTED ON ENTRY SIGNED BY INMAN ETC, KUPERMAN DID NOT SIGN ENTRY. C/ATTYS

Document Available (#1040396701) TIFF    PDF

07-09-2018  TEXT

WITHDRAW OF COUNSEL-RICHARD BELL

Document Available (#1040394842) TIFF    PDF

07-10-2018  TEXT

JE: IN FOLLOWING CASES (115557, 115558, 115717) W/DRAWAL OF COUNSEL OF ATTY BELL SH/BE TREATED AS MOT TO W/DRAW. APLNT WILL CONT TO BE REP BY BURKE AND GREEN EXCEPT FOR CASE 115717 WH/IN APLNT WILL CONT TO BE REP BY BURKE. MOT TO W/DRAW GRANTED. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1040395208) TIFF    PDF

09-17-2018  TEXT

JE: I H/BY RECUSE MYSELF ETC. WYRICK, J. C/ATTYS WCM

Document Available (#1040390915) TIFF    PDF

09-18-2018  OPIN

JE: MEMORANDUM OPINION------------------------------AFFIRMED--------------------------COMBS, CJ. CONCUR: COMBS, CJ, WINCHESTER, DARBY, JJ. CONCUR BY REASON OF STARE DECISIS: KAUGER, EDMONDSON, JJ. DISSENT: GURICH, VCJ, REIF, J. RECUSED: COLBERT, WYRICK, JJ. C/ATTYS WCM PRESS WEST OBJ MDC (2018 OK 70)

Document Available (#1041587011) TIFF    PDF

09-18-2018  1004

AFFIRMED (OPINION)

10-17-2018  MAND

MANDATE ISSUED

Document Available (#1041589380) TIFF    PDF

10-17-2018  RELW

RELEASE CARD SENT TO WEST

10-19-2018  TEXT

ORGR RECEIVED FROM COURT

10-19-2018  RRWC

RECORD RETURNED WORKERS COMP.

10-22-2018  RCMD

RECEIPT FOR MANDATE