The information contained in this report is provided in compliance with the Oklahoma Open Records Act, 51 O.S. 24A.1. Use of this information is governed by this act, as well as other applicable state and federal laws.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA

Jessica Dalene Evans, individually and on behalf of H.E., Minor Child, Kayla Ashley Jackson, Individually and on behalf of C.M., Minor Child,
Plaintiffs,

vs

Jon Randall Ishmael,
Defendant/Appellee,

Title II Firearms, Inc.,
Intervenor/Appellant,

J. Peter Messler,
Appellee.
No. DF-118278
(District Court Final Order or Judgment)


Filed: 09/27/2019
Closed: 11/17/2021

Appealed from: TULSA County District Court

Parties

ISHMAEL, JON RANDALL, Appellee
MESSLER, J PETER, Appellee
Title II Firearms, Inc, Appellant
 

Attorneys

Attorney Represented Parties
COHRS,  FORREST (Bar #32755)
624 S BOSTON SUITE 900
TULSA, OK 74119
 
 
Haskins,  Walter  D (Bar #3964)
525 S Main ST
Suite 1500
Tulsa, OK 74103
 
Title II Firearms, Inc
Lyons,  Mark  D (Bar #5590)
Lyons & Clark Inc
Two Main Plaza
616 South Main Suite 201
Tulsa, OK 74119
 
ISHMAEL  JON  RANDALL
MESSLER,  JAMES  P (Bar #6156)
1500 S. UTICA AVE.
SUITE 400
TULSA, OK 74104
 
 
Palfreyman,  Kirsten  Louise (Bar #30668)
Holden Litigation
15 East 5th Steet, Suite 3900
Tulsa, OK 74103
 
Title II Firearms, Inc
SWARTZ,  CHARLES  R (Bar #22313)
MID-CONTINENT TOWER
401 S. BOSTON AVE., SUITE 1600
TULSA, OK 74103
 
 

Events

  None

Lower Court Counts and Other Information

Count Case Number Statute Crime Sentence Judge Reporter
- CJ-2017-3704 - Morrissey, Linda G.

Docket

Date Code Description Count Party Amount
09-03-2019  DOOA

DATE OF ORDER APPEALED

09-26-2019  MAIL

PETITION MAILED DATE

09-27-2019  CASE

DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING

09-27-2019  PAY

RECEIPT # 76099 ON 09/27/2019.
PAYOR: WALTER D HASKINS III TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 200.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$200.00 ON DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING.

09-27-2019  PETF

PETITION IN ERROR FILED BY HASKINS FOR TITLE II FIREARMS - INTERVENOR/APLNT

Document Available (#1044687544) TIFF    PDF

09-27-2019  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY WALTER D. HASKINS

Document Available (#1044687548) TIFF    PDF

09-27-2019  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY KIRSTEN L. PALFREYMAN

Document Available (#1044687552) TIFF    PDF

09-27-2019  DSRC

DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1044687556) TIFF    PDF

10-15-2019  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY MARK D. LYONS

Document Available (#1044687679) TIFF    PDF

10-15-2019  RESP

DEFT/APLEE, JON RANDALL ISHMAEL'S RESPONSE TO PETITION IN ERROR

Document Available (#1044687683) TIFF    PDF

10-15-2019  ECON

APPELLEE AGREEABLE TO SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

10-15-2019  DSRC

COUNTER-DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1044687687) TIFF    PDF

10-18-2019  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY J. PETER MESSLER

Document Available (#1044686650) TIFF    PDF

01-02-2020  APIE

AMENDED PETITION IN ERROR (MAIL)

Document Available (#1044683346) TIFF    PDF

01-02-2020  DSRC

AMENDED DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1044683350) TIFF    PDF

02-28-2020  TEXT

NOTICE OF COMPLETION W/INDEX

Document Available (#1046000872) TIFF    PDF

05-26-2020  TEXT

JE: ETC, ATBC SH/BE FILED NLT 6-30-20, OR APPEAL MAY BE DSMD. ETC. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1046003243) TIFF    PDF

06-26-2020  TEXT

APLNT TITLE II FIREARMS, INC'S UNOPPOSED MOTION TO SUSPEND BRIEFING DEADLINES

Document Available (#1046939066) TIFF    PDF

06-29-2020  TEXT

JE: APLNT'S UNOPPOSED MOT TO SUSP BRIEFING ETC GRANTED. APLNT SH/FILE ATBC W/IN 2 WEEKS OF FILING OF AMENDED NTCP. IF AMENDED NTCP NOT FILED BY 7-29-20, APLNT SH/FILE STATUS REP REGARDING STATUS ETC. N/ATTYS DC CLERK

Document Available (#1046939114) TIFF    PDF

07-06-2020  NTCP

SUPPLEMENTAL NOTICE OF COMPLETION W/SUPPLEMENTAL INDEX

Document Available (#1046939870) TIFF    PDF

07-13-2020  ATBC

APPELLANT'S BRIEF IN CHIEF

Document Available (#1046941815) TIFF    PDF

08-06-2020  AEAB

ANSWER BRIEF OF APPELLEE JON RANDALL ISHMAEL

Document Available (#1046937871) TIFF    PDF

08-26-2020  ATRB

APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF

Document Available (#1046937050) TIFF    PDF

08-27-2020  RORD

RECORD ORDERED

09-04-2020  ORGR

3 VOLUME ORIGINAL RECORD - 598 PAGES; 1 EXHIBIT BINDER

09-04-2020  TRAN

2 VOLUME TRANSCRIPT APR. 25 & 30, 2018 - 316 PAGES

09-04-2020  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 3/14/18 - 30 PAGES

09-04-2020  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 2/27/19 - 11 PAGES

09-04-2020  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 8/20/19 - 19 PAGES

09-09-2020  CCAO

ASSIGNED TO COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS, OKLAHOMA CITY; N/ATTYS

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

03-11-2021  COPN

JE: OPINION--------------------AFFIRMED IN PART AND REVERSED IN PART---------------------PRINCE, J. CONCURS: MITCHELL, J. GOREE, PJ., CONCURS IN PART AND DISSENTS IN PART ETC. ----------------------SUMMARY-------------------C/ATTYS DC JUDGE

Document Available (#1048388418) TIFF    PDF

03-11-2021  1204

AFFIRMED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART (OPINION)

03-22-2021  TEXT

DEF/APLEE'S APPLICATION FOR APPEAL-RELATED COSTS COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048388101) TIFF    PDF

03-26-2021  TEXT

DEFENDANT/APPELLEE'S APPLICATION FOR APPEAL RELATED ATTORNEY FEES COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048389544) TIFF    PDF

03-31-2021  CREH

APLNT'S PETITION FOR REHEARING AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048388217) TIFF    PDF

03-31-2021  TEXT

APLNT TITLE II FIREARMS, INC.'S MOTION TO COMPEL TULSA COUNTY COURT CLERK TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048388221) TIFF    PDF

04-06-2021  TEXT

INTERVENOR/APLNT'S OBJECTION TO DEFT/APLEE'S APPLICATION FOR APPEAL-RELATED COSTS COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048389298) TIFF    PDF

04-06-2021  TEXT

INTERVENOR/APLNT'S OBJECTION TO DEFT/APLEE'S APPLICATION FOR APPEAL-RELATED ATTORNEY FEES COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048389294) TIFF    PDF

04-06-2021  TEXT

INTERVENOR/APLNT'S MOTION FOR APPEAL ATTORNEY FEES COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048389290) TIFF    PDF

04-06-2021  TEXT

INTERVENOR/APLNT'S MOTION FOR APPEAL COSTS**********ADD 237.75 COST TO MANDATE**********

Document Available (#1049354683) TIFF    PDF

04-09-2021  TEXT

JE: CT CONSIDERED MOT TO COMPEL ETC. APLNTS HAVE BURDEN TO MONITOR PREP OF APPELLATE REC ETC. CT DENIES MOT TO COMPEL ETC. C/ATTYS DC CLERK DC JUDGE COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048396616) TIFF    PDF

04-14-2021  CRHD

JE: APLNT'S PET FOR REHE DENIED. C/ATTYS OBJ COA/OKC

Document Available (#1048396659) TIFF    PDF

04-22-2021  TEXT

DEFT/APLEE'S RESPONSE AND OBJECTION TO INTERVENOR/APLNT'S MOTION FOR APPEAL RELATED COSTS COA/OKC

Document Available (#1049354690) TIFF    PDF

04-22-2021  TEXT

DEFENDANT/APPELLEE'S RESPONSE AND OBJECTION TO INTERVENOR/APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR APPEAL ATTORNEY FEES COA/OKC

Document Available (#1049353534) TIFF    PDF

04-23-2021  TEXT

DEF/APLEE'S REPLY TO INTERVENOR/APLNT'S OBJECTION TO DEF/APLEE'S APPLICATION FOR APPEAL-RELATED ATTORNEY FEES COA/OKC

Document Available (#1049355378) TIFF    PDF

04-27-2021  TEXT

JE: APLNT'S MOT FOR APPEAL RELATED ATTY FEES GRANTED. MATTER REMANDED TO TR/CT FOR EVIDENTIARY HEARING AND DETERMINATION OF REASONABLE ATTY FEE ETC. C/ATTYS DC JUDGE COA/OKC

Document Available (#1049354250) TIFF    PDF

04-27-2021  TEXT

JE: APLNT'S MOT FOR APPEAL COSTS GRANTED IN PART. CLERK SHALL TAX COSTS ETC. C/ATTYS COA/OKC******COSTS OF $237.75 PREVIOUSLY TAXED 4-6-21**********

Document Available (#1049355408) TIFF    PDF

04-27-2021  TEXT

JE: APLEE'S APPL FOR APPEAL-RELATED ATTY FEES DENIED. C/ATTYS COA/OKC

Document Available (#1049355412) TIFF    PDF

04-27-2021  TEXT

JE: APLEE'S APPL FOR APPEAL-RELATED COSTS GRANTED IN PART. CLERK SH/TAX COST ETC. C/ATTYS COA/OKC**************ADD $95.10 COSTS TO MANDATE***************

Document Available (#1049355416) TIFF    PDF

05-05-2021  PAY

RECEIPT # 80341 ON 05/05/2021. BY MAIL
PAYOR: WALTER D HASKINS III TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 100.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$100.00 ON PET FOR CERT #118278.

05-05-2021  CERT

APLNT'S PET FOR CERT (MAIL) COA/OKC

Document Available (#1049354257) TIFF    PDF

05-11-2021  TEXT

JE: APLNT TITLE II FIREARMS TO SH/CAUSE NLT 5-26-21, WHY CERT PROCEEDING SH/NOT BE DSMD AS UNTIMELY ETC. C/ATTYS

Document Available (#1049351541) TIFF    PDF

05-17-2021  TEXT

NTERVENOR/APLNT'S RESPONSE TO SHOW CAUSE ORDER

Document Available (#1049354861) TIFF    PDF

05-24-2021  TEXT

ORGR RECEIVED FROM CCAO

10-25-2021  CTDE

JE: APLNT'S PET FOR CERT DENIED. CONCUR: KANE, VCJ, KAUGER, WINCHESTER, EDMONDSON, COMBS, ROWE, KUEHN, JJ. CONCUR IN PART, DISSENT IN PART: GURICH, J. NOT PRESENT: DARBY, CJ. N/ATTYS COA/OKC

Document Available (#1050531483) TIFF    PDF

11-12-2021  RRCD

RECORD RETURNED TO DISTRICT COURT ***DATE CORRECTED***

11-17-2021  MAND

MANDATE ISSUED

Document Available (#1050877942) TIFF    PDF

12-01-2021  RCMD

RECEIPT FOR MANDATE