The information contained in this report is provided in compliance with the Oklahoma Open Records Act, 51 O.S. 24A.1. Use of this information is governed by this act, as well as other applicable state and federal laws.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA

Norris Auto Sales, LLC, an Oklahoma limited liability company, Firris Birris Kline, an individual and T.J. Norris, an individual,
Plaintiffs/Appellees,

vs.

Zurich American Insurance Company and Universal Underwriters Insurance Company,
Defendants/Appellants.
No. DF-120050
(District Court Final Order or Judgment)


Filed: 12/03/2021
Closed: 11/21/2024

Appealed from: OKLAHOMA County District Court

Parties

KLINE, FIRRIS BIRRIS, Appellee
NORRIS, T J, Appellee
Norris Auto Sales, LLC, Appellee
Universal Underwriters Insurance Company, Appellant
Zurich American Insurance Company, Appellant
 

Attorneys

Attorney Represented Parties
BOTTOM,  MONTY  B (Bar #987)
201 Robert S. Kerr
12th Floor
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
 
 
CALVERT,  RANDALL  K (Bar #14154)
CALVERT LAW FIRM
1041 NW GRAND BOULEVARD
OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73118
 
Norris Auto Sales, LLC
KLINE  FIRRIS  BIRRIS
NORRIS  T  J
DAVIS,  ANDREW  R (Bar #32763)
CALVERT LAW FIRM
1041 NW GRAND BOULEVARD
OKC, OK 73118
 
Norris Auto Sales, LLC
KLINE  FIRRIS  BIRRIS
NORRIS  T  J
Fischer,  Amy  Sherry (Bar #16651)
201 ROBERT S KERR AVE, 12TH FLOOR
OKLA CITY, OK 73102
 
Zurich American Insurance Company
OTTAWAY,  LARRY  D (Bar #6816)
201 ROBERT S KERR AVE
12TH FLOOR
OKC, OK 73102
 
Zurich American Insurance Company
Universal Underwriters Insurance Company
Schiller,  Ronald  P
One Logan Square, 27th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103
 
Zurich American Insurance Company
Universal Underwriters Insurance Company
Wiygul,  Robert  A
One Logan Square, 27th Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103
 
Zurich American Insurance Company
Universal Underwriters Insurance Company

Events

  None

Lower Court Counts and Other Information

Count Case Number Statute Crime Sentence Judge Reporter
- CJ-2015-5686 - Stinson, Sheila

Docket

Date Code Description Count Party Amount
11-04-2021  DOOA

DATE OF ORDER APPEALED

12-03-2021  CASE

DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING

12-03-2021  PAY

RECEIPT # 82260 ON 12/03/2021.
PAYOR: MONTY B BOTTOM TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 200.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$200.00 ON DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING.

12-03-2021  PETF

PETITION IN ERROR FILED BY BOTTOM FOR ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE ET AL-DEFS/APLNTS

Document Available (#1051087753) TIFF    PDF

12-03-2021  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY MONTY B. BOTTOM

Document Available (#1051087757) TIFF    PDF

12-03-2021  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY LARRY D. OTTAWAY

Document Available (#1051087761) TIFF    PDF

12-03-2021  DSRC

DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1051087765) TIFF    PDF

12-07-2021  TEXT

APLNTS' MOT TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL - RONALD P. SCHILLER AND ROBERT A. WIYGUL

Document Available (#1051087032) TIFF    PDF

12-08-2021  TEXT

JE: APLNTS' MOT TO ASSOC SCHILLER AND WIYGUL ETC GRANTED. CT NOTES COMPLIANCE ETC. SCHILLER AND WIYGUL SH/FILE ENTRIES OF APP ETC NLT 12-21-21. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1051087801) TIFF    PDF

12-10-2021  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY RONALD P. SCHILLER

Document Available (#1051087819) TIFF    PDF

12-10-2021  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ROBERT A. WIYGUL

Document Available (#1051087823) TIFF    PDF

12-22-2021  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ANDREW R. DAVIS

Document Available (#1051088767) TIFF    PDF

12-22-2021  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY RANDALL K. CALVERT

Document Available (#1051088771) TIFF    PDF

12-22-2021  RESP

RESPONSE TO PETITION

Document Available (#1051088775) TIFF    PDF

12-22-2021  DSRC

COUNTER-DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1051088779) TIFF    PDF

12-30-2021  DSRC

AMENDED DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1051380151) TIFF    PDF

04-19-2022  TEXT

LETTER DATED 4-14-22 TO MONTY BOTTOMS FROM DIST CT CLERK

Document Available (#1051912820) TIFF    PDF

04-27-2022  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY AMY SHERRY FISCHER

Document Available (#1051913110) TIFF    PDF

04-27-2022  TEXT

APLNTS' MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1051913106) TIFF    PDF

04-28-2022  TEXT

JE: APLNT'S MOT FOR EXT OF TIME TO FILE NTCP OF REC GRANTED. NTCP OF REC SH/BE FILED NLT 6-3-22. ETC. N/ATTYS DC CLERK

Document Available (#1051913069) TIFF    PDF

06-01-2022  DSRC

SECOND AMENDED DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Unavailable (#1052477143)

06-03-2022  TEXT

NOTICE OF COMPLETION W/INDEX

Document Available (#1052476539) TIFF    PDF

06-06-2022  NTCP

NOTICE OF COMPETION W/INDEX

Document Available (#1052476479) TIFF    PDF

06-13-2022  TEXT

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD BY MONTY B. BOTTOM

Document Available (#1052477298) TIFF    PDF

06-16-2022  TEXT

JE: MOT OF ATTY MONTY B. BOTTOM TO W/DRAW AS ATTY FOR DFNT/APLNTS ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO AND UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO IS GRANTED, ATTY BOTTOM IS PERMITTED TO W/DRAW. DFNTS/APLNTS WILL CONT TO BE REP IN TH/MATTER BY LARRY D. OTTOWAY AND AMY SHERRY FISCHER, ETC. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1052477350) TIFF    PDF

08-02-2022  ATBC

BRIEF IN CHIEF OF APLNTS ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY AND UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE COMPANY

Document Available (#1052968397) TIFF    PDF

08-02-2022  TEXT

APPENDIX TO BRIEF IN CHIEF OF APLNTS'

09-12-2022  AEAB

ANSWER BRIEF OF PLNTFS/APLEES

Document Available (#1053479678) TIFF    PDF

09-13-2022  TEXT

APLNTS' UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE REPLY BRIEF

Document Available (#1053479675) TIFF    PDF

09-14-2022  TEXT

JE: APLNTS' MOT FOR EXT OF TIME TO FILE ATRB IS GRANTED. ATRB SH/BE FILED NLT 10-17-22. ETC. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1053479269) TIFF    PDF

10-17-2022  ATRB

REPLY BRIEF OF APLNTS ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY AND UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE COMPANY

Document Available (#1053481046) TIFF    PDF

10-21-2022  RORD

RECORD ORDERED

10-27-2022  ORGR

6 VOLUME ORIGINAL RECORD - 1885 PAGES; 5 EXHIBIT ENVELOPES; 2 EXHIBIT BINDERS; 6 BOUND DOCUMENTS (SEE INDEX OF RECORD PAGES 275, 1047, 1089, 1141, 1196 AND 1426)

10-27-2022  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 7/27/2018 - 32 PAGES

10-27-2022  TRAN

5 VOLUME TRANSCRIPT APR. 9 THROUGH 13, 2018 - 756 PAGES

10-27-2022  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 10/8/2021 - 37 PAGES

10-27-2022  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 10/11/2021 - 167 PAGES

10-27-2022  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 10/12/2021 - 187 PAGES

10-27-2022  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 10/13/2021 - 192 PAGES

11-02-2022  CCAT

ASSIGNED TO COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS, TULSA; N/ATTYS

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

11-16-2022  TEXT

APLEES' MOTION TO DISQUALIFY JUDGE OF THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS COA/TULSA

Document Available (#1053898069) TIFF    PDF

01-30-2024  TEXT

JE: ETC. UNDERSIGNED JUDGE H/BY DISQ FR/PARTICIPATION ETC. HIXON, J. ETC. HON WISEMAN, IS ASSIGNED TO SIT IN AND DECIDE ETC. C/ATTYS DC JUDGE COA/TULSA

Document Available (#1057356934) TIFF    PDF

05-24-2024  COPN

JE: OPINION---------------REVERSED AND REMANDED----------------HUBER, PJ. CONCURS: WISEMAN, J. (ETC). BLACKWELL, J., DISSENTING ETC.----------------SUMMARY---------------C/ATTYS DC JUDGE

Document Available (#1058189231) TIFF    PDF

05-24-2024  3014

REVERSED AND REMANDED (OPINION)

06-13-2024  PAY

RECEIPT # 89150 ON 06/13/2024. OVER THE COUNTER
PAYOR: LARRY D OTTAWAY TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 100.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$100.00 ON PET FOR CERT #120050.

06-13-2024  CERT

DEFS/APLNTS' CONDITIONAL PETITION FOR CERTIORARI ($/OC) COA/TULSA

Document Available (#1058189790) TIFF    PDF

06-13-2024  PAY

RECEIPT # 89155 ON 06/13/2024.
PAYOR: RANDALL K CALVERT TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 100.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$100.00 ON PET FOR CERT 120050.

06-13-2024  CERT

PLNTFS/APLEES' PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI ($/OC) COA/TULSA

Document Available (#1058189444) TIFF    PDF

06-28-2024  CERA

DEFTS/APLNTS' ANSWER IN OPPOSITION TO PLNTFS/APLEES' PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Document Available (#1058773909) TIFF    PDF

06-28-2024  CERA

PLNTFS/APLEES' ANSWER TO DEFTS/APLNTS' PETITION FOR CERTIORARI

Document Available (#1058773684) TIFF    PDF

07-08-2024  CERR

DETFS/APLNTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF CONDITIONAL PETITION FOR CERTIORARI

Document Available (#1058190146) TIFF    PDF

07-12-2024  CERR

PLNTFS/APLEES' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Document Available (#1058190540) TIFF    PDF

08-19-2024  TEXT

ORGR RECEIVED FROM CCAT

10-28-2024  CTDE

JE: BOTH PETS FOR CERT DENIED. CONCUR: KANE, CJ, ROWE, VCJ, KAUGER, WINCHESTER, EDMONDSON, COMBS, GURICH, KUEHN, JJ. N/ATTYS COA/TULSA

Document Available (#1059898880) TIFF    PDF

11-21-2024  MAND

MANDATE ISSUED

Document Available (#1059900451) TIFF    PDF

11-25-2024  RCMD

RECEIPT FOR MANDATE

11-26-2024  RRCD

RECORD RETURNED TO DISTRICT COURT (P/U)