The information contained in this report is provided in compliance with the Oklahoma Open Records Act, 51 O.S. 24A.1. Use of this information is governed by this act, as well as other applicable state and federal laws.

IN THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA
Tulsa

Patrick S. Ryan, and Chris M. Williams,
Petitioners/Appellees,

vs

State of Oklahoma ex rel., Oklahoma Real Estate Appraiser Board,
Respondent/Appellant.
No. DF-121564
(District Court Final Order or Judgment)


Filed: 08/30/2023
Closed: 12/31/2025

Appealed from: OKLAHOMA County District Court

Parties

Oklahoma Real Estate Appraiser Board, Appellant
Ryan, Patrick S, Appellee
Williams, Chris M., Appellee
 

Attorneys

Attorney Represented Parties
Birnie,  Charles  Austin (Bar #31942)
Frederic Dorwart, Lawyers PLLC
124 East Fourth Street
Tulsa, OK 74103
 
Ryan  Patrick  S
Williams  Chris  M.
McCaleb,  Stephen  L. (Bar #15649)
2500 McGee Drive Sutie 140
Norman, OK 73072
 
Oklahoma Real Estate Appraiser Board
Ward,  Stephen  R (Bar #13610)
CONNER & WINTERS LLP
4100 FIRST PLACE TOWER
15 EAST FIFTH STREET
TULSA, OK 74103
 
 

Events

  None

Lower Court Counts and Other Information

Count Case Number Statute Crime Sentence Judge Reporter
- CV-2022-1986 - Dishman, C. Brent

Docket

Date Code Description Count Party Amount
08-01-2023  DOOA

DATE OF ORDER APPEALED

08-30-2023  CASE

DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING

08-30-2023  PAY

RECEIPT # 87125 ON 08/30/2023.
PAYOR: STEPHEN L MCCALEB TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 200.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$200.00 ON DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING.

08-30-2023  PETF

PETITION IN ERROR FILED BY MCCALEB FOR OKLAHOMA REAL ESTATE APPRAISER BOARD-RSPNT/APLNT

Document Available (#1056219001) TIFF    PDF

08-30-2023  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY STEPHEN L. MCCALEB

Document Available (#1056219005) TIFF    PDF

09-19-2023  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY STEPHEN R. WARD

Document Available (#1056508982) TIFF    PDF

09-19-2023  RESP

RESPONSE TO PETITION IN ERROR

Document Available (#1056508978) TIFF    PDF

09-19-2023  DSRC

COUNTER-DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1056508986) TIFF    PDF

01-31-2024  TEXT

JE: ETC. UNLESS NTCP OF REC IS FILED BY 2-15-24, APPEAL W/BE SUBJECT TO DSML W/OUT FURTHER NOTICE. ETC. N/ATTYS DC CLERK

Document Available (#1057356898) TIFF    PDF

01-31-2024  TEXT

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS - STEPHEN L. MCCALEB

Document Available (#1057356935) TIFF    PDF

02-05-2024  TEXT

LETTER DATED 1-31-24 TO STEPHEN L. MCCALEB FROM DC CLERK

Document Available (#1057357463) TIFF    PDF

02-09-2024  TEXT

LETTER DATED 2-9-24 TO RICK WARREN FROM ATTY STEPHEN L. MCCALEB

Document Available (#1057356998) TIFF    PDF

02-14-2024  NTCP

NOTICE OF COMPLETION W/INDEX

Document Available (#1057357641) TIFF    PDF

03-29-2024  TEXT

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL - C. AUSTIN BIRNIE

Document Available (#1057691430) TIFF    PDF

04-01-2024  TEXT

JE: CT NOTES ATTY BIRNIE'S MOT TO W/DRAW ETC. CT FURTHER NOTES NO ENTRY OF APP WAS SIGNED AND FILED IN APPEAL BY BIRNIE ETC. IN ABSENCE OF ANY SIGNED ENTRY OF APP BY BIRNIE, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. APLEES WILL CONT TO BE REP BY ATTY WARD WHO FILED SIGNED ENTRY OF APP IN APPEAL. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1058183686) TIFF    PDF

04-15-2024  ATBC

APPELLANT'S ANSWER BRIEF

Document Available (#1058184455) TIFF    PDF

05-24-2024  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY C. AUSTIN BIRNIE

Document Available (#1058772085) TIFF    PDF

05-24-2024  AEAB

ANSWER BRIEF OF PETRS/APLEES PATRICK S. RYAN AND CHRIS M. WILLIAMS

Document Available (#1058772089) TIFF    PDF

05-28-2024  TEXT

MOTION OF COUNSEL FOR PETRS-APLEES, CONNER & WINTERS, LLP, TO WITHDRAW - STEPHEN R. WARD

Document Available (#1058189167) TIFF    PDF

06-04-2024  TEXT

JE: MOT OF ATTY WARD TO W/DRAW AS ATTY ETC GRANTED, AND ATTY WARD PRMTD TO W/DRAW. APLEES WILL CONT TO BE REP BY BIRNIE, WHO PREVIOUSLY ENTERED APP ETC. N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1058189614) TIFF    PDF

06-14-2024  ATRB

APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF

Document Available (#1058189820) TIFF    PDF

06-21-2024  RORD

RECORD ORDERED

07-02-2024  ORGR

ORIGINAL RECORD - 1303 PAGES; 2 VOLUME ADM. RECORD

07-02-2024  TRAN

TRANSCRIPT 5/17/2023 - 27 PAGES

07-11-2024  TEXT

JE: FOLLOWING ITEM W/DESIGNATED BUT W/NOT INCLUDED IN REC ON APPEAL ETC. (SEE ORDER TH/DATE). OKLA CO DIST CT CLERK SH/SUPP REC ON APPEAL W/ABOVE DESCRIBED ITEM OR ADVISE TH/CT WHY TH/CANNOT BE ACCOMPLISHED NLT 8-8-24 OR TH/MATTER MAY CONT W/OUT ITEM IN REC. C/ATTYS DC CLERK DC JUDGE

Document Available (#1058190274) TIFF    PDF

07-25-2024  CCAT

ASSIGNED TO COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS, TULSA; N/ATTYS

Document Available (#1055675495) TIFF    PDF

11-25-2025  COPN

JE: OPINION---------------AFFIRMED-----------------HUBER, J. CONCUR: BARNES, PJ., HIXON, VCJ.----------------SUMMARY-----------------C/ATTYS DC JUDGE

Document Available (#1062690868) TIFF    PDF

11-25-2025  1004

AFFIRMED (OPINION)

12-31-2025  MAND

MANDATE ISSUED

Document Available (#1064051281) TIFF    PDF

01-08-2026  RCMD

RECEIPT FOR MANDATE

01-20-2026  TEXT

ORGR RECEIVED FROM CCAT

01-20-2026  RRCD

RECORD RETURNED TO DISTRICT COURT (P/U)