The information contained in this report is provided in compliance with the Oklahoma Open Records Act, 51 O.S. 24A.1. Use of this information is governed by this act, as well as other applicable state and federal laws.

IN THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA
Oklahoma City

Derby Exploration, LLC, and PEO Oklahoma, LLC,
Plaintiffs/Appellees,

vs

Comanche Exploration Company, LLC,
Defendant/Appellant.
No. DF-122148
(District Court Final Order or Judgment)


Filed: 05/01/2024
Closed: 07/17/2025

Appealed from: DEWEY County District Court

Parties

Comanche Exploration Company, LLC, Appellant
Derby Exploration, LLC, Appellee
PEO Oklahoma, LLC, Appellee
 

Attorneys

Attorney Represented Parties
Brockman,  Matthew  Wayne (Bar #22077)
Hartzog Conger Cason
201 Robert S. Kerr Ave.
Suite 1600
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
 
Comanche Exploration Company, LLC
Elder,  David  Allen (Bar #20687)
Hartzog Conger Cason
201 Robert S. Kerr
Suite 1600
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
 
Comanche Exploration Company, LLC
FOSTER,  ZACHARY  J (Bar #30554)
MAHAFFEY & GORE, PC
300 NE 1ST STREET
OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73104
 
Derby Exploration, LLC
Gore,  Richard (Bar #3479)
Mahaffey & Gore, P.C.
300 NE 1st Street
Oklahoma City, OK 73104
 
 
Whaley,  Michael (Bar #33640)
Hartzog Conger Cason
201 Robert S. Kerr
Suite 1600
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
 
Comanche Exploration Company, LLC

Events

  None

Lower Court Counts and Other Information

Count Case Number Statute Crime Sentence Judge Reporter
- CV-19-30 - Harrel, Celo

Docket

Date Code Description Count Party Amount
04-15-2024  DOOA

DATE OF ORDER APPEALED

05-01-2024  CASE

DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING

05-01-2024  PAY

RECEIPT # 88848 ON 05/01/2024.
PAYOR: MATTHEW W BROCKMAN TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 200.00.
LINE ITEMS:
$200.00 ON DISTRICT COURT FINAL ORDER OR JUDGMENT INITIAL FILING.

05-01-2024  PETF

PETITION IN ERROR FILED BY BROCKMAN FOR COMANCHE EXPLORATION COMPANY, LLC-DEFT/APLNT

Document Available (#1058184525) TIFF    PDF

05-01-2024  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY DAVID A. ELDER

Document Available (#1058184529) TIFF    PDF

05-01-2024  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY MATTHEW W. BROCKMAN

Document Available (#1058184533) TIFF    PDF

05-01-2024  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY MICHAEL P. WHALEY

Document Available (#1058184537) TIFF    PDF

05-01-2024  DSRC

DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1058184541) TIFF    PDF

05-21-2024  TEXT

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ZACHARY J. FOSTER

Document Available (#1058189148) TIFF    PDF

05-21-2024  RESP

PLNTS/APLEES' RESPONSE TO PETITION IN ERROR

Document Available (#1058189144) TIFF    PDF

05-21-2024  DSRC

COUNTER-DESIGNATION OF RECORD

Document Available (#1058189140) TIFF    PDF

08-08-2024  NTCP

NOTICE OF COMPLETION W/INDEX

Document Available (#1058774243) TIFF    PDF

10-07-2024  ATBC

APPELLANT'S BRIEF IN CHIEF

Document Available (#1059561578) TIFF    PDF

11-18-2024  AEAB

APPELLEE'S ANSWER BRIEF

Document Available (#1060367646) TIFF    PDF

12-09-2024  ATRB

APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF

Document Available (#1059900069) TIFF    PDF

12-13-2024  RORD

RECORD ORDERED

12-20-2024  ORGR

ORIGINAL RECORD - 187 PAGES

12-20-2024  TRAN

3 VOLUME TRANSCRIPT OCT. 31 THROUGH NOV. 2, 2022 - 667 PAGES

01-09-2025  CCAO

ASSIGNED TO COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS, OKLAHOMA CITY; N/ATTYS

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

06-20-2025  COPN

JE: OPINION----------------AFFIRMED----------------GOREE, PJ. CONCURS: SWINTON, PRINCE, J------------------------SUMMARY---------------------C/ATTYS DC JUDGE

Document Available (#1061870171) TIFF    PDF

06-20-2025  1004

AFFIRMED (OPINION)

07-17-2025  MAND

MANDATE ISSUED

Document Available (#1062195993) TIFF    PDF

07-23-2025  RCMD

RECEIPT FOR MANDATE

07-28-2025  TEXT

ORGR RECEIVED FROM CCAO

07-28-2025  RRCD

RECORD RETURNED TO DISTRICT COURT (USPS)