The information contained in this report is provided in compliance with the Oklahoma Open Records Act, 51 O.S. 24A.1. Use of this information is governed by this act, as well as other applicable state and federal laws.
IN THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA
Oklahoma City
| Stacy Alan and Joyce Lynn Bean; Carilyn Joyce Beebe, individually, and as trustee of the Joyce Beebe trust; Greg and Teena Bergdall; Lloyd and Peggy Bixler; Kelly Craig; Merle and Kim Dennett; Lora Dierksen; Vera M. Dierksen, individually, and as trustee of the Loren R. Dierksen trust; Loren R. Dierksen, individually, and as trustee of the Vera M. Dierksen trust; Kelly and Sylvia Earhart; Eric M. And Laura Hoffenberg; Gary and Suzanne Hunter; Cindy McNaughton; Jenny Root; Donald and Lea Anne Smith; J. Scott Witty and Thu C. Turner; Kent Walker; Reid and Mattie Weber; Kenneth Wehrenberg; and Shirley a. West, individually, and as trustee of the Shirley A. West trust, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. Skeleton Creek Energy Center, LLC.; Nextera energy resources, LLC.; Jerald Gibert, in his official capacity as city manager of Enid; David Mason, in his official capacity as mayor of Enid; city of Enid, Oklahoma; and board of county commissioners of Garfield County, Defendants/Appellees. |
No. SD-123569 (Summary Disposition) Filed: 11/21/2025 Appealed from: GARFIELD County District Court |
Parties
Alan, Stacy,
Appellant
Bean, Joyce Lynn,
Appellant
Beebe, Carilyn Joyce,
Appellant
Bergdall, Greg,
Appellant
Bergdall, Teena,
Appellant
Bixler, Lloyd,
Appellant
Bixler, Peggy,
Appellant
Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County,
Appellee
City of Enid, Oklahoma,
Appellee
Craig, Kelly,
Appellant
Dennett, Kim,
Appellant
Dennett, Merle,
Appellant
Dierksen, Lora,
Appellant
Dierksen, Loren R.,
Appellant
Dierksen, Vera M.,
Appellant
Earhart, Kelly,
Appellant
Earhart, Sylvia,
Appellant
Hofferber, Eric M.,
Appellant
Hofferber, Laura,
Appellant
Hunter, Gary,
Appellant
Hunter, Suzanne,
Appellant
McNaughton, Cindy,
Appellant
Nextera Energy Resources, LLC,
Appellee
Root, Jenny,
Appellant
Skeleton Creek Energy Center, LLC,
Appellee
Smith, Donald,
Appellant
Smith, Lea Anne,
Appellant
Turner, Thu C.,
Appellant
Walker, Kent,
Appellant
Webber, Maddie,
Appellant
Weber, Reid,
Appellant
Wehrenberg, Kenneth,
Appellant
West, Shirley A.,
Appellant
Witty, J. Scott,
Appellant
Attorneys
| Attorney | Represented Parties |
|---|---|
| Cajindos, Justin R (Bar #36063) EIGHT FLOOR, TWO LEADERSHIP SQURE 211 N. ROBINSON AVE OKC, OK 73102 |
City of Enid, Oklahoma |
| Coffin, April B (Bar #31965) Gum, Puckett & Mackechnie, LLP 105 North Hudson, Suite 900 Oklahoma City, OK 73102 |
Alan Stacy Bean Joyce Lynn Beebe Carilyn Joyce Bergdall Greg Bergdall Teena Bixler Lloyd Bixler Peggy Craig Kelly Dennett Kim Dennett Merle Dierksen Lora Dierksen Loren R. Dierksen Vera M. Earhart Kelly Earhart Sylvia Hofferber Eric M. Hofferber Laura Hunter Gary Hunter Suzanne McNaughton Cindy Root Jenny Smith Donald Smith Lea Anne Turner Thu C. Walker Kent Webber Maddie Weber Reid Wehrenberg Kenneth West Shirley A. Witty J. Scott |
| Gum, Robert G. (Bar #3659) Gum, Puckett & Mackechnie, L.L.P. 105 N. Hudson Avenue, Suite 900 Oklahoma City, OK 73102 |
Alan Stacy Bean Joyce Lynn Beebe Carilyn Joyce Bergdall Greg Bergdall Teena Bixler Lloyd Bixler Peggy Craig Kelly Dennett Kim Dennett Merle Dierksen Lora Dierksen Loren R. Dierksen Vera M. Earhart Kelly Earhart Sylvia Hofferber Eric M. Hofferber Laura Hunter Gary Hunter Suzanne McNaughton Cindy Root Jenny Smith Donald Smith Lea Anne Turner Thu C. Walker Kent Webber Maddie Weber Reid Wehrenberg Kenneth West Shirley A. Witty J. Scott |
| Humphries, Tommy Wayne (Bar #19130) 108 S. Independence Enid, OK 73701 |
Board of County Commissioners of Garfield County |
| Knox, David Michael (Bar #36701) Gum, Puckett & Mackechnie, LLP 105 N. Hudson Ave. Suite 900 Oklahoma City, OK 73102 |
Alan Stacy Bean Joyce Lynn Beebe Carilyn Joyce Bergdall Greg Bergdall Teena Bixler Lloyd Bixler Peggy Craig Kelly Dennett Kim Dennett Merle Dierksen Lora Dierksen Loren R. Dierksen Vera M. Earhart Kelly Earhart Sylvia Hofferber Eric M. Hofferber Laura Hunter Gary Hunter Suzanne McNaughton Cindy Root Jenny Smith Donald Smith Lea Anne Turner Thu C. Walker Kent Webber Maddie Weber Reid Wehrenberg Kenneth West Shirley A. Witty J. Scott |
| MILLER, JENNIFER L (Bar #19888) PHILLIPS MURRAH PC 424 NW 10TH ST STE 300 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73102 |
Skeleton Creek Energy Center, LLC Nextera Energy Resources, LLC |
| SHINN, RONALD JR (Bar #19569) HB LAW PARTNERS PLLC PO BOX 668 NORMAN, OK 73070 |
City of Enid, Oklahoma |
| Wood, Randall J (Bar #10531) Pierce Couch Hendrickson 1109 N. Francis P O Box 26350 Okla City, OK 73126 |
|
Events
None
Lower Court Counts and Other Information
| Count | Case Number | Statute | Crime | Sentence | Judge | Reporter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| - | CV-2024-140 | - | Newby, Tom |
Docket
| Date | Code | Description | Count | Party | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
DATE OF ORDER APPEALED |
|||
|
|
|
SUMMARY DISPOSITION INITIAL FILING |
|||
|
|
|
RECEIPT # 93126 ON 11/21/2025. |
|||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
APPELLANT'S RECORD-SUMMARY DISPOSITION VOLS 1-8 (O+4) |
|||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
REVERSED AND REMANDED (OPINION) |